The AI Paradox: If It Can’t Replace Us, Is It Making Us Less Intelligent?

Alright, folks, let’s talk about the paradox of AI. I mean, yeah, sure—AI can’t exactly replace us. We’ve all read those headlines: “AI Takes Jobs,” “Chatbots to Replace Customer Service Reps,” and the occasional “AI Now Writes Better Love Letters Than You Ever Did” (not that it’s hard, buddy, you just haven’t been loved enough).

But here’s a thought: What if AI isn’t just taking jobs? What if it’s taking away our ability to think?

Hold on, hold on—don’t throw your smart gadgets out the window just yet. Let’s dig into this, in my style, starting with.

AI is Our New Best Friend or Brain Drain?

Remember when we used to Google stuff? It’s like, how many calories are in an apple? Then, you’d scroll through forums and pages to find one reliable source. Sometimes it even led us through rabbit holes.

Well, not that’s not so long ago.

Now? Nah. Just ask ChatGPT and boom! Instant answer.

Need a 5-day meal plan that caters to your gluten intolerance? A friendly AI will whip one up before you even finish your morning coffee. It’s magic, right? Like a genie that doesn’t grant three wishes but answers infinite random questions.

But let’s get real: Are we getting lazier—or dare I say—dumber? AI use cases are exponentially growing every day, even as I am scripting this blog I bet some dude from his dorm is coming up with weird ideas to put AI to use in our lives.

We’ve got AI tools solving our math problems, drafting our emails, and even telling us the most efficient route to Starbucks. But what happens to our brain muscles when they’re no longer lifting the weight of everyday tasks?

Here is a study from The University of Sydney that sheds light on what exactly happens in the brain while performing complex tasks. When we stop challenging ourselves, our cognitive skills can atrophy, kind of like a gym membership we’ve neglected since New Year’s.

It is AI vs Dopamine, Which Should be Ideally AI and Dopamine

Think about it. You’re swiping through TikTok or Instagram, and those cute AI-generated memes or voiceover dogs pop up—hilarious, right? And I am not even getting into the influence of generative AI on the political advertising in 2024.

Instant dopamine hit.

AI-powered recommendations know exactly what makes us tick. And it’s not just TikTok. Netflix’s AI knows what you wanna watch even before you do.

Now, don’t get me wrong, I’m as guilty as the next person of binging an entire season of Game of Thrones (old seasons) in one weekend.

But it’s a little unnerving, isn’t it? The way AI reads us like an open book, feeding our brain with easy pleasures, which—according to neuroscientists—gives us quick dopamine hits, but nothing in the way of genuine satisfaction.

There’s this 2022 study from the Cureus Journal of Medical Science that found an increase in screen time, correlates with

Declining Physical, Psychological Health, and Sleep Patterns. It also affects the parts of the brain associated with critical thinking and emotional regulation. It’s like feeding your brain a diet of marshmallows instead of a balanced meal. Sure, it feels good, but after a while, you’re missing out on the brainy nutrients—complex problem-solving, analytical thinking, and self-reflection.

Story Time

Oh, and I’ve got stories, plenty of them.

Ever heard about people using ChatGPT to write their wedding vows? Yeah, because nothing says commitment like a chatbot-generated “I promise to always do the dishes.” The best part? Most people won’t even notice. And maybe that’s cute in a sitcom way, but isn’t it a bit unsettling that we’re outsourcing our deepest expressions to machines?

When AI does the heavy lifting, our brains chill on a virtual hammock, sipping Piña Coladas while forgetting how to get back to work.

So, the Cost of Convenience is leading to Brainpower on the Decline?

Now, let’s talk about the real paradox here: AI makes life easier, no doubt.

It’s helping us discover new drugs, predict climate change impacts, and even save the bees (and if we don’t save the bees, we’re in big trouble, right?). But the question is, are we paying a hidden price for all this convenience?

Take language learning, for example. Why bother memorizing vocabulary when your phone can translate for you? There’s evidence—like a study from Frontiers in Psychology—that suggests when people rely too much on digital tools for memory tasks, their brain’s hippocampus (that part responsible for memory) becomes less active. In other words, it’s the mental equivalent of skipping leg day. Okay not everyone is Joey when it comes to learning new languages.

Or how about basic math skills? No need to know your multiplication tables when your smartphone has a built-in calculator. But get this—Christina Miles, a researcher from Old Dominion University found that students who regularly use calculators during problem-solving exercises tend to have a weaker grasp of numerical concepts compared to those who work things out manually. It’s like, we’ve got all the answers at our fingertips, but are we forgetting how to ask questions?

It is just a TOOL, let’s say it Together Again

Alright, let’s not get too dystopian here. I mean, AI isn’t some evil overlord plotting to turn us into mindless zombies (though The Terminator might have you think otherwise). It’s just a tool—like a hammer. It can build or it can destroy, depending on how you use it.

The problem is, we’re starting to use it like a Swiss Army knife that does everything. And that means we’re relying on it for stuff we used to handle ourselves. The real question is, where do we draw the line? When do we step back and say, “Hey, maybe I should figure this out myself instead of asking the virtual assistant”? It’s like cooking—yeah, a meal kit subscription is great, but you might miss out on the joy (or pain) of learning to sauté without setting off the smoke alarm.

So, Is AI Making Us Dumber?

Well, let’s break it down. AI makes life easier. No doubt about it. It’s helping scientists, doctors, and even pizza delivery drivers work more efficiently. But when it comes to the rest of us—folks who aren’t busy sequencing genomes or exploring Mars—there’s a risk of cognitive atrophy.

We’ve got AI doing the hard thinking while our brains sit back and enjoy the ride. And that, my friends, is the paradox.

As the good ol’ philosopher Descartes might say (with a bit of a twist): “I think, therefore I am… Oh, wait, I let my chatbot think for me. Am I still?”

My Point is…

Look, I’m not saying we should all throw our gadgets into a bonfire and go back to reading maps and growing our own food. AI is here to stay, and it’s doing a lot of good. But maybe, just maybe, we should challenge ourselves a little more. Solve that Sudoku without the app. Write a thank-you note without asking ChatGPT for a template. Teach your kid to tie their shoes without relying on YouTube.

Let’s keep those brain muscles from turning to mush. After all, it’s not about ditching the tech—it’s about not letting it ditch us.

---

This article was originally published by Anderson on HackerNoon.